Marketing

How to evaluate an SEO proposal: a checklist for B2B companies

In short

How do you evaluate an SEO proposal? Check whether it was written for your company or could have gone to anyone. A proposal worth signing names the searches and pages it will work on, says how you'll check the result in your own Search Console, and leaves your accounts with you. Google's own guidance on hiring an SEO says no one can promise a #1 ranking on Google, so set aside any proposal that offers one.

Below: what a proposal for a B2B or industrial company should show, the questions to ask, the warning signs, and a table and checklist for comparing two or three. There are no price rows on purpose: price only means something once you know what it buys.

Checked against Google Search Central's guidance on hiring an SEO and the Search Console help documentation, and Alkali's first-hand experience scoping SEO for B2B companies, November 2026.

Summarize with AI
  • A side-by-side comparison for two or three proposals, row by row
  • A 24-point checklist to tick, print or download
  • Sourced to Google's docs and our own SEO scoping work
Jump to the checklist↓

What an SEO proposal should pin down before you sign

The planNamed, not general
Searches it targets
Listed
Why each one
Buyer intent
Pages built or changed
By name
Broad category terms
Ask why
Your processes, lines and markets, in buyers' words

The plan: searches and pages

Which searches, why those, and which pages will answer them, named before any work starts.

The measureSearch Console
Baseline
Before work
Impressions on planned terms
Monthly
Clicks to planned pages
Monthly
Quote requests by source
Your count
Read from your own Search Console, not a tool score

The measure: how you'll know

What will move, in what order, and where you can check it yourself without asking the agency.

The termsRead before signing
Search Console owner
Your company
Agency access
Added as a user
Notice to leave
Find the date
Promised position
Walk away
Accounts and history stay with you if you leave

The terms: what you keep

Who owns the accounts, how long you're committed, and what leaving costs, settled on paper.

Why don't two SEO proposals line up?

Because they're usually selling different things, built on different guesses about your business.

They price different work

One is a one-time audit, another a monthly program, a third folds search into a website rebuild. All three are legitimate shapes, the ones on our SEO services page among them.

An audit or discovery proposal can't name your pages or searches yet, because the agency hasn't seen inside your Search Console. Judge it on what the audit will produce and by when.

They guessed at your business

Google's page on hiring an SEO says a good one should ask what makes your business unique, who your competitors are and how your customers find you. One that didn't ask is planning for a generic company.

They promise different evidence

One reports rankings, one traffic, one a tool's score, and the most flattering number tends to win. Pick the measure first and hold every proposal to it.

On two discovery calls in November 2026, prospects asked us for evidence rather than opinion: one wanted to see what buyers actually search for, the other wanted something showing the work does what it claims. That's the right instinct to bring to an SEO proposal, and the rows below turn it into questions.

What should an SEO proposal for a B2B company include?

Six things. None needs SEO knowledge to check: each is on the page or missing.

  • The searches it will go after, and why those

    Named terms built from your processes, materials, product lines, industries and service areas. A list of broad category terms is planning for traffic, not for quote requests.

  • The pages it will build or change

    Which pages get rewritten, which get written, and which search each one answers. "Content optimization" with no page names can't be checked later.

  • How you'll know it worked, in Search Console terms

    A baseline before work starts, then clicks and impressions on the planned pages in your own Search Console. Google leaves queries searched by no more than a few dozen people over two to three months out of its query tables, so for small industrial terms the page numbers are the steadier read. Quote requests come last, from your own count.

  • Who writes, and how they'll get the detail

    The writer by role, how they'll get tolerances and certifications out of your engineers, and who approves technical accuracy.

  • What you'll see every month

    Work shipped with dates, movement on the planned pages, and what the agency will change because of it. A count of posts published is activity, not a report.

  • Terms you can live with

    The commitment length, the notice needed to leave, and whose accounts the work and its history live in.

Which questions should you ask before signing?

The first three are from the questions Google's page on hiring an SEO suggests putting to any candidate, lightly reworded; the last three are ours. Put the same ones to every agency and write the answers down.

  1. What results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe?

    A good answer

    A sequence with rough timing tied to named pages: technical fixes, then impressions, then clicks and quote requests. A single number with a date is a promise nobody controls.

  2. How do you measure success?

    A good answer

    In Search Console against a baseline, and against the quote requests your own team counts. A third-party score is a rough gauge, not what happened on Google.

  3. Will you share every change you make to the site, and why?

    A good answer

    Yes, with a log of what changed, on which page, on what date, and the reasoning.

  4. Which of our pages would you leave alone?

    A good answer

    Something specific. An agency that has looked at your site can name the pages already doing their job.

  5. What access do you need, and in whose account?

    A good answer

    Your company stays the owner and adds the agency as a user. While it's still auditing, Google suggests granting read access to Search Console only, not write.

  6. What happens if the plan isn't working at month three?

    A good answer

    A named check you can both see, such as impressions on the planned pages, and what they'd change if it hasn't moved. "SEO takes time" is true and isn't an answer.

Once a contract is signed, the checks change. The first 30 days with a new agency covers that stage.

What are the red flags in an SEO proposal?

The first five come from Google's own page on hiring an SEO. The last is worth checking in any proposal sent to a B2B company.

A promised ranking

Google's advice is to find someone else if an SEO says its changes will put you in first place. A promised position in a proposal is the fastest reason to set it aside.

A special line to Google

Google warns about SEOs that allege a "special relationship" with Google or advertise a "priority submit". Appearing in its organic results costs nothing, so there's no faster route to buy.

Secret methods

Google says to be careful if a company is secretive or won't clearly explain what it intends to do. "Proprietary process" with no detail is exactly that.

It started with a cold email about your rankings

Google says to be wary of SEO firms that email you out of the blue. An audit nobody asked for isn't a diagnosis.

Link schemes and "thousands of search engines"

Google says to avoid SEOs that talk about link popularity schemes or submitting your site to thousands of search engines, and that you should never have to link to an SEO. It doesn't endorse third-party SEO tools, so a "Google-approved" tool isn't.

Google's page also asks whether advice on optimizing for AI answers, sold as AEO or GEO, lines up with its own guidance on generative AI features. Ask any proposal selling it to cite that guidance. SEO vs. GEO explains how the two relate.

How do you compare two or three SEO proposals side by side?

Give each proposal its own column and fill in the same thirteen rows from what the document actually says. Anything you can't fill in goes back to the agency as a written question.

Side-by-side rows13 rows
RowWrite down, for each proposalWhat a strong proposal shows
Diagnosis
What it says is wrong with your site todaySpecific findings from your pages, or for an audit, what it will produce and when
Target searches
The terms it namesYour processes, lines and markets, with the reason for each
Pages
Which pages it creates or changesNamed pages, each tied to a search
Out of scope
What it says it won't doA written list, so nothing is assumed
Baseline
When and how it's capturedBefore any work, from your own accounts
Measure of success
What number it will reportImpressions and clicks on the planned pages, plus query data
Link to quote requests
How search work is tied to inquiriesForm tracking plus your team's count by source
Dated plan
Work and dates for the first three monthsNamed work with dates, not "ongoing optimization"
Team and writer
Who does the work and writes the pagesNamed roles; your experts supply and approve the specifics
Monthly report
What it containsWork shipped, movement, and the next decision
Account ownership
Whose login owns Search Console and analyticsYour company owns them; the agency is a user
Term and exit
Length, notice period, what you keepA notice date you can find and work you keep
Red flags
Any from the list aboveNone

If two still tie, weight the rows before you reread them, the way the RFP scoring matrix weights a website project, so the better-presented document doesn't win by default.

The SEO proposal checklist

Work through it once for each proposal. Ticks save in this browser, or download it as Word or PDF and keep one copy per proposal.

AlkaliThe SEO proposal checklistbyalkali.com/resources/seo-proposal-checklist/
0 of 24 done
  1. Before you ask for proposals

    A little homework on your side makes every proposal comparable.

    0/4
  2. What the proposal must show

    A missing item becomes a written question. For an audit-first proposal, the searches and pages come later: check it gives a date for them.

    0/12
  3. Red flags: none of these

    Any one of the first three is reason enough to set the proposal aside.

    0/5
  4. Terms to read before signing

    The contract decides more than the proposal does.

    0/3

What if every proposal misses a few rows?

That's normal. Send each agency its blank rows as written questions and give them a week. A firm that fills the gaps with specifics has been thinking about your site; one that sends back the same paragraph hasn't.

If none can name the searches or pages, the problem may be upstream. A short SEO audit checklist you run yourself finds the basic problems first, and SEO for manufacturers covers which industrial searches tend to matter.

Sources

  1. Do you need an SEO? Tips for hiring an SEO (Google Search Central, last updated 2026-06-05)developers.google.com
  2. Managing owners, users, and permissions (Search Console Help)support.google.com
  3. Performance report: clicks, impressions, CTR and average position (Search Console Help)support.google.com
  4. A deep dive into Search Console performance data filtering and limits (Google Search Central Blog, 2022-10-19)developers.google.com
SEO (search engine optimization)Website auditDomain authorityVendor lock-inContent gap analysisSearch indexingAI search optimization (GEO)
Share
What is an SEO proposal?
A document an SEO agency or consultant sends a prospective client describing the work they'd do to improve its visibility in search, how results will be measured, and the terms. A good one is specific enough that you could check every line of it a few months later.
How to measure success of SEO?
In Google Search Console, against a baseline taken before the work started. It reports impressions, clicks, click-through rate and average position, by query and by page. Watch the planned pages first: Google leaves rarely searched queries out of the query tables, so page totals catch small industrial terms the query list misses. Then count quote requests by source yourself, because many arrive by phone and never show up in analytics.
Can an SEO company promise first-page rankings?
No. Google's own guidance on hiring an SEO says no one can promise a #1 ranking on Google, and to find someone else if an SEO says its changes will put you in first place. A proposal can commit to the work: which pages, for which searches, by when.
What should an SEO proposal for a manufacturing company include?
Everything a B2B proposal should, plus two things that matter more for a manufacturer. First, how it treats specification-level searches, such as a material, tolerance or process paired with an industry: they're small, and a good proposal targets them anyway and says why. Second, how much engineer time it needs, in hours a month for interviews and review, and who signs off technical accuracy. A proposal that assumes none will likely come back asking for it later.
How many SEO proposals should we compare?
Two or three is usually enough. In our experience, past that the comparison tends to drift toward whichever document is easiest to read. Send each agency the same brief and compare them on the same rows.
Who should own Search Console when an agency does our SEO?
Your company. Search Console lets an owner add and remove users, so an employee should hold the owner role and add the agency as a user, which keeps the history with you if the agency changes. Google's page on hiring an SEO suggests granting only read access to Search Console while an agency audits the site.

Let's build something together.

A 30-minute call. We'll listen, dig into the details, and tell you honestly whether we're the right partner, or point you to someone who is.

Book Intro Call ↗